We’ve written multiple times about Kirby Ferguson’s excellent Everything is a Remix project that has produced three videos highlighting the problems and history of intellectual property and how copying and derivative works are a core element of culture and invention. He’s now released the fourth and final installment in the series, and it’s a great summary look at the general problems with intellectual property law today.
The key theme is that the theory (treating ideas, inventions, content, etc. as a form of “property” — in the minds of many copyright and patent system supporters) simply doesn’t match up with reality (where almost everything is a derivative work of some sort). What the video does nicely is highlight the hypocrisy of it all. As he notes brilliantly, when we copy (and everyone does copy), we justify it. When others copy, however, suddenly we attack them and vilify them. A perfect recent example of this, by the way, was former NYT executive editor Bill Keller’s bizarre defense of the NYT copying and posting a work covered by someone else’s copyright, just days after his own column came out in support of greater legal enforcement of copyrights.
Sometime later I’ll make a post explaining my views on intellectual property. These videos are certainly interesting.
-
theveganarchist liked this
-
imall4frogs liked this
-
blowinmahnose liked this
-
subhangsmind reblogged this from anticapitalist
-
brachiate reblogged this from anticapitalist
-
pre2pre liked this
-
orioleorgans liked this
-
arielnietzsche liked this
-
bestidealist liked this
-
arielnietzsche reblogged this from anticapitalist
-
anticapitalist posted this
